Is there an Actor in the House? a review of … Earnest?
On a bustling Monday evening, the New Theatre Cardiff was alive with energy, packed to the rafters for … Earnest?, a show by the inventive theatre company Say It Again, Sorry? It was a heartening sight for those invested in the future of the Arts. To see such enthusiasm for a performance that deviates from conventional theatre underscores the appetite audiences have for bold, interactive productions that push the boundaries of what the theatrical experience can offer.
This reinterpretation of Oscar Wilde’s classic comedy brought not only laughs but an evening of utterly unpredictable entertainment. From the outset, it was clear that this was a production like no other. The supposed star of the show, Earnest, was missing—and the audience was tasked with filling in the gaps. What followed was a whirlwind of improvisation as willing (and some nervously volunteered!) audience members stepped into the spotlight, supported by the cast’s witty guidance.
What makes ..Earnest? so compelling is its spontaneity. Every performance is unique, with audience members contributing to its unpredictable hilarity. For those watching the antics unfold, the atmosphere was electric. It was impossible not to laugh at the quick reactions of both the cast and the courageous members of the audience who took their turn on stage. The cast’s remarkable ability to adapt—never missing a beat despite unexpected responses from their impromptu co-stars—is what gives this production its charm and momentum.
The director, Simon Slough, portrayed by Josh Haberfield, was a standout, skilfully balancing his role as both a long-suffering mediator and an inventive leader. His knack for working with and improvising around the audience members was genius. Guido Garcia Lueches, as Algernon, brought flawless comedic timing to the role, while Rhys Tees and the rest of the cast kept the chaos organised with unwavering commitment.
Beyond the stellar performances, the humour, and the immersive audience participation, there’s a broader significance to a show like ...Earnest?. It demonstrates the richness and variety of the theatre world—proving that performances don’t have to adhere to a strict script or traditional staging to be impactful. It is a celebration of creativity, risk, and collaboration, which felt incredibly relevant and inspiring in a packed theatre on a weekday night.
“an evening of utterly unpredictable entertainment”
Plus, It’s a testament to the power of community and the joy that live theatre can bring to audiences. Seeing everyone cheer on the volunteers stepping into Wilde’s timeless roles, and watching the cast expertly navigate the unpredictable nature of the show, fostered a strong sense of camaraderie. It was a reminder of why theatre remains such a vital part of cultural life.
For anyone looking for a night of non-stop laughter, smart improvisation, and chaos wrapped in clever craftsmanship, … Earnest? is a must-see. And perhaps even a must-repeat—it’s the kind of show that beckons you back for a completely new experience.
With productions like this breathing fresh life into the Arts, we can only hope that more theatres and Production companies continue to innovate and inspire. It’s not just a performance; it’s a experience. Oscar would surely approve (but maybe not be in the front row!).
